Hallie Foote, left, and Elizabeth Ashley star in the Alley Theatre s production of Horton Foote's "Dividing the Estate.": Alley TheaterNo playwright has ever known his chosen milieu and people better than Horton Foote knew small-town Texas and its plainspoken inhabitants forever struggling to keep life from getting the best of them.
Foote’s perception was never more acute — nor turned to more unexpectedly hilarious effect — than in Dividing the Estate.
A late triumph of Foote’s seven-decade career, Dividing the Estate makes its Houston premiere at the Alley Theatre, with director Michael Wilson re-creating his inspired 2008 Broadway production, showcasing an ideal cast anchored by the irreplaceable Elizabeth Ashley and Hallie Foote in the two most prominent roles.
The action unfolds in 1987 in Harrison, Foote’s fictionalized version of his hometown of Wharton, where three generations of the once-lordly Gordon family gather to scheme and squabble about ways to stave off financial ruin, amid the pressures of falling property value, unpaid taxes and the ’80s oil bust.
Feisty matriarch Stella manipulates her three offspring by pitting them against each other. Widowed daughter Lucille, and her Son (that’s what they call him) live with Stella and draw modest salaries since Lucille looks after the house and Son manages the estate. Naturally, they side with Stella in her effort to preserve the status quo.
But Stella’s alcoholic son, Lewis, needs money to get out of his latest scrape, and daughter Mary Jo arrives from Houston with husband Bob and two teen daughters, the whole family facing bankruptcy after living beyond their means for years. Lewis, Mary Jo and Bob campaign to divide and sell the property and get what they can now.
The family struggle plays out amid unexpected events and other currents, including three generations of serving staff, and Son’s schoolteacher fiancee, Pauline, the only person who takes note of larger social forces that will affect them all.
Roger Robinson as Doug in a scene from "Dividing the Estate" at the Alley Theatre.: Alley TheaterAn instant classic of American family life, Estate ranks with Foote’s finest work. His handling of the densely layered action and character interplay is expert and true. While maintaining his trademark authenticity and sympathy, he achieves a sharper edge by tipping the balance from his customary tender elegy to wryly observant comedy. Yet by the play’s close, the dramatic impact has registered: the passing of a way of life and a stage full of people at a loss to cope with change.
It’s a play whose combination of technical mastery and human understanding could have been achieved only through long years of living and artistic exploration.
Likewise, Wilson’s years of staging Foote’s plays pay off handsomely with a production perfectly attuned to the dramatist’s vision. We get the sardonic alarm at certain characters’ behavior, but we also understand the desperation driving them. The rendition could scarcely be better paced or more apt at registering how the atmosphere changes depending on which characters are sharing the stage.
Ashley, a major Broadway star since the 1960s, brings her throaty vigor and authoritative presence to Stella — the old girl’s arbitrary willfulness and meandering memory giving way to the ferocity of a tigress when defending a pet cause or person.
Hallie Foote’s selfish, relentlessly calculating Mary Jo is a masterpiece of comic characterization. Pouncing like a prim vulture with “How much will I get?” queries, tossing tantrums and tirades or frozen in helpless inaction, she’s sad yet hysterical.
Penny Fuller’s warm and well-defined Lucille catches her reliable and resentful sides, formidably feisty when necessary. As Lewis, James Black movingly enacts that Foote fixture, the weak man troubled and shamed by his inability to best his demons. James DeMarse’s bluff, jovial, desperately finagling Bob is spot-on as the Houston real-estate tycoon whiz suddenly in financial free-fall.
Roger Robinson gives a vital, richly textured portrayal of Doug, the proud, 92-year-old family retainer. Devon Abner’s Son at times has a hint of Henry Fonda — dutiful yet increasingly fed up at shouldering burdens. As his bright, altruistic intended, Maggie Lacy is humorously out of sync with the Gordons’ greed and combativeness. Pat Bowie instills patient housekeeper Mildred with knowing bite.
Jeff Cowie’s exquisitely detailed setting recalls Broadway’s golden age and master designers such as Jo Mielziner.
As the Alley’s first Foote project since the playwright’s death in 2009, Dividing the Estate inevitably carries an air of valedictory — a play and production to cherish.
DIVIDING THE ESTATE
When: 7:30 p.m. Tuesdays-Thursdays, 8 p.m. Fridays, 2:30 and 8 p.m. Saturdays, 2:30 and 7:30 p.m. Sundays, through Oct. 30
Where: Alley Theatre, 615 Texas
Tickets: $25-$87; 713-220-5700
Saw it Tuesday. Best show I've seen in years. Extremely funny.
Went to see this on Thursday. Left at intermission. Don't know what this reviewer was watching. Other than Elizabeth Ashley and the actor playing Doug, the cast was unwatchable. Painfully so. And Hallie Foote was the worst. If you're looking for over the top caricature, maybe you'd like her performance. She stomped around the stage, swinging her arms like a robot. You can tell a real actor by watching what she does when she's not talking. She seemed to be thinking about her next line. I realize that you want this to be good, given the local author connection. Even for a "homer", I don't know how you give this a positive review. We saw "August Osage County" on Broadway. Much better writing, direction and acting.
I saw 'Dividing'opening night and loved. The show was great. You should have stayed for the 2nd Act. As a native Texan and Professional Union actor for 25 years, I can vouch for the characters. People act like that in East Texas..plus it should be funny. If you want to watch drama watch drama. Don't go see a comedy and then complain it wasnt serious enough. The acing not true..the acting my dear was brilliant. People that leave at intermision..well..thay should just stay home in the first place and watch NCIS....
I have seen lots of Horton Foote and thought Dividing the Estate was smart and funny. Much less a soap opera than August: Osage County. I lived for many years in Richmond, Texas so the small town pride and defensiveness rang true. How sad to see your family disintegrate along with your hometown! I liked the cast as a whole, many of them from Michael Wilson's production of Orphan's Home Cycle which I hope will arrive in Houston soon.
I saw this production last night and enjoyed it very much. I have seen almost every Horton Foote play and admire his heartfelt dialogue. Having lived in Richmond, Texas for many years I understood the fierce pride and disappointment the family felt for their crumbling town. Richmond/Rosenberg also suffered from the Whataburgers and especially from Walmart.
I liked the cast a lot - most of them from the wonderful Orphan's Home Cycle that I saw 2 years ago in NYC. Hope Michael Wilson and the Alley bring that to Houston!
I have to agree with Lynnic. I saw the Sunday matinee. I liked the story, but the acting left much to be desired. Son was wooden, and so was Mary Jo. Multiple times, it seemed the dialogue was being read instead of spoken. The second act dragged.
I'm with the other two that thought Mary Jo sucked. Hallie Foote is one of those actresses that everyone sucks up to because her dad was Horton Foote. The man's dead. It's time to admit she's terrible.
We saw this play Tuesday night, we are season ticket holders for 10 years now and we were so grossly disappointed. We left during intermission. There was no comedic content, the characters were ALL whiney and without backbone and the writing was monotonous beyond description. Only my own family comes this close to boring me to tears.
It's disappointing to read this kind of review and then subsequently to read through audience comments in this section. It gives one pause and reason to question whether one can trust the reviews read in this paper. Labeling an actor or actress "irreplaceable" ? I work in the theatre, and I know from my years of experience that NO ONE is "irreplaceable." Given the ephemeral nature of the art form, perhaps what our reviewer observed was a very "on" night; but given the general consensus among guests writing here, I have my suspicions. Readers and the Alley Theatre both deserve an honest assessment, Mr. Evans. Please don't disappoint us. There are enough bad shows out there to do that.
Post new comment